The Payments Market
Redesigned Payments Market hero with a single Get a quote button
Redesigned Payments Market homepage copy that leads with the visitor's problem
Shortened Payments Market quote form with only the questions needed to qualify a lead
Unbuilt second version of the results page with smaller cards and the best deal highlighted
The Payments Market additional screen
The Payments Market additional screen
The Payments Market additional screen
The Payments Market additional screen
The Payments Market additional screen
The Payments Market additional screen
Close

Payments comparison — Web App ©2025

The Payments Market logo

The Payments Market

The Payments Market helps businesses compare card payment providers, whether they want to cut their fees or take cards for the first time. The site wasn't converting, so I redesigned it to bring in more leads, and better ones.

The Payments Market redesigned homepage on desktop

The problem

The homepage explained who The Payments Market were, listed their partners and outlined the concept. It never made it obvious why a business should care.

Then it asked visitors to pick between two CTAs, one for switching providers and one for businesses new to card payments, before they'd even understood what they'd get. The form after that had enough friction to lose most people before they reached their results.

The original Payments Market homepage with two competing calls to action

Who uses it

Two kinds of business come to the site. Ones already taking cards who think they're paying too much, and ones that don't take cards yet. Both want to see their options quickly.

The client needs something different. Leads that are qualified enough to be worth following up. The redesign had to work for both.

Key decisions

One CTA instead of two

The two CTAs were meant to be helpful. In practice they made people categorise themselves before they knew what the site could do for them. I cut them down to one, Get a quote. Whether you're new or switching is now a question inside the form, where it actually belongs.

Redesigned Payments Market hero with a single Get a quote button

Copy that starts with the user's situation

I rewrote the homepage to lead with the visitor's problem, not the product's features. If you're paying too much on card fees, or you don't take cards yet, this is for you. Framed that way, the CTA reads like the obvious next step instead of a commitment.

Redesigned Payments Market homepage copy that leads with the visitor's problem

A shorter form

The form was the main drop-off point. I put every question through one simple test. Does the client genuinely need this to qualify a lead, or is it just nice to have? Anything that didn't pass got cut.

Shortened Payments Market quote form with only the questions needed to qualify a lead

Results you can take in at a glance

Each result card was showing so much that it overwhelmed people instead of helping them. I redesigned the cards so the most relevant details come first, with more available if you want to dig in. From there, users can apply directly or request a callback.

Redesigned results page with provider cards showing the most relevant details first
Expanded provider result card with options to apply directly or request a callback

Result

More leads, and better ones. People reaching the results page are genuinely further along in deciding, which is what the client cared about most.

What I'd have shipped next

I designed a second version of the results page that never got built, because the project was shelved. The cards were smaller and easier to move through, and the best deal for each business was clearly highlighted.

Unbuilt second version of the results page with smaller cards and the best deal highlighted

The bigger lesson for me is that sites built to convert need treating like products, not pages. There's almost always something worth improving.

Need help with your next project? Let’s talk.

Book a call →Book a call →Book a call →
←BOX logoPrevious projectNext projectHighful Minds logo→

This website uses Cookies

AcceptAcceptAccept